Showing posts with label Middle East. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Middle East. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

On pictures and words

If 1 picture > 1000 words, could you watch 473 pictures and say you've read The Lord of the Rings?

Could you take 50 snapshots, and claim to have "won" NaNoWriMo? 

Could you query an agent, pretending that you only took 80 pictures, while you actually sneaked (sorry, Tami, snuck) an additional 12 into the album?

I think not. Though sometimes a picture is worth quite a lot of words. Like this one: 


By my count, it is worth 179 words. 

You'll have to swing by Burrowers, Books & (today more than ever) Balderdash to find out which words. 


Wednesday, November 3, 2010

On my alternative solution...

...to the Middle East conflict:




...they may need more giraffes. 





Brought to you by Wordless Wednesday, and a fatigued historian...

(...and too many ellipses...) 

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

On Peace One Day

When I was in Japan in 2006 I was invited to a local celebration of Peace One Day. I had no idea what Peace One Day was, but after a quick introduction in the car on our way there, and then a viewing of the Peace One Day movie, I begun to realize I had just become part of something big. Our local Akita celebration hardly tore down any walls, but I think that the people who participated (I know I did) felt that we had been empowered to go out in the world and spread the word about what Peace One Day is all about. That is what I am doing right now.

Peace One Day is a concept developed by filmmaker Jeremy Gilley who in 1999 decided to try to convince the world community that just one day of world peace could be the starting point for something much bigger. His initial goal was to make September 21st the United Nations official day of peace. In 2001 this was achieved, with the 192 member nations voting for adopting this day as an annual day of global ceasefire and non-violence. Peace One Day had won its first victory, but the project was not over.

Since 2001 the work of Jeremy and his organization has spread the word about Peace One Day. The new goal is to reach out to 3 billion people by 2012. Peace Day is supposed to be a day of non-violence, both between nations, within countries, and between individual people. Call me a hippie, but if we can make 3 billion people stop being violent in every aspect of their lives for just one day each year, that is one hing of an accomplishment.

This year I think the thought behind Peace One Day holds a particular meaning to me. I’m finally in the process of putting the finishing touches on my thesis. For two years I have been surrounded by narratives, images, old documents and history books – all telling various aspects of the same tragic story. The people in the Middle East has been living in a state of war, or under the threat of war, for more than 60 years. After having seen what it does to me to only hear about it for two years, I can’t imagine what it must feel like to live in the middle of it a lifetime.

The current negotiations offers a slim, but much needed hope. I can’t say that I believe it is as easy as a signed document in front of a smiling Obama (and I’m not even saying I believe that will happen). But I have to hope. One day of peace will not save the Middle East either, but again I want us to hope. Hope that each day without war will somehow make the world slightly better. That perhaps we eventually can talk about Peace One Week, or Peace One Month. That enough people will be convinced that peace is the way to go, and that war is not.

Thus I encourage you to take part in this. Spread the word about Peace One Day. Raise the awareness. Remember that if just one man could do all this, then perhaps it is time the rest of us start paying attention.


Happy International World Peace Day!
http://www.youtube.com/peaceoneday


Also - in a slightly related vein I'd like to tell you about another, much smaller project. Imagine that one good deed set in motion a chain of events that lead to a slightly better day for each person affected. In August, The Burrow invited a number of our friends to participate in a drabble cycle - inspired by a post by B. Miller - where each mini-story covers a selfless action that helps another human (and in one case an extra-terrestial) being. The Burrow Pay It Forward project will only be up a few more days before a new project is due, so I urge you to visit www.the-burrow.org ASAP to get a chance to read all the drabbles.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

On glaciers

I’m going to tell you a little secret. Way back in high school, when I was young and innocent and full of dreams (if you’re laughing now, I’m ignoring it), I never had any doubts that I would one day not only write books, but publish them by the large. Oh yes. I saw myself as the new [insert random successful author], and I thought it was only a matter of time before the world would realize it.


Even though I was young and innocent and full of dreams, however, I was also somewhat realistic. I knew that my books wouldn’t make me rich and famous immediately (what I didn’t know was that I also wouldn’t write any books the next few years – I still haven’t). So I decided that I needed an education. A solid job, which should even be one that I liked, so that I could fill my days until my big break came with something meaningful. The education part has taken its time, but I am getting there. And I wouldn’t be without it. I have grown as a person, I have gained experiences I otherwise would not, and I have a whole new range of strings to play on as a writer now than did I all those years ago.

And yet there are a few things that I came up with back then that I still consider funny or brilliant enough to match anything I have ever written since. For instance, I have several times found myself marveling over a (sadly) long-forgotten inventiveness when reading stuff I wrote years ago. The grammar, language and style bothers me to the bone, but 17-year-old Cruella had a fresh way of seeing the world that I only rarely manage to recall.

One of the things that really triggered my creativity when I was 17 was my partner in crime, otherwise known as Amalie Skam (very funny if you know your Norwegian literature, I can assure you. As is Cruella Collett, by the way). We used to write collaborative stories of various literary quality. We invented new words and actually, even a religion (this would be the origin of Digressionism). Ah, those were the days.

Ms. Skam and I are still friends, but we rarely get together to invent religions these days. However, I haven’t forgotten one idea we concocted when we were young and innocent and full of dreams. The idea was that in my books there should always be a female glaciologist. You know, a scientist who does her research on glaciers. Why? Don’t know or can’t remember. But that was it. A hidden glaciologist as a secret message.

Thus, my surprise and amazement was considerable when I came across the following document in my Middle East files in US State Department archives:






It clearly has nothing to do with the Middle East (any glaciers down there would melt in a flash). Either it was put in my box by mistake, or it was put there by intent. I would have been inclined to think the former, but keeping my lost connection with Cruella at 17 in mind, I soon realized that it just as well could have been the latter. In fact, all the evidence is suggesting that this is a hidden message, and that it is a hidden message to me. Just look at this:





But the problem remains. What is the hidden message? Could it be that the universe is simply telling me to rediscover my inner 17-year-old?

Thursday, May 27, 2010

On knowing someone (or not actually knowing them at all)

You’ve all had the feeling – you thought you knew someone, and then – like a bolt from the blue – they do a 360 degrees on you and you have no idea who this person is after all. I’ve recently had this happen to me. Worse, I was not able to confront the person in question, since he died some 30 years ago. At least that is what I thought…


I realize this needs clarification. Alright, let me try. In the work of my master’s thesis [oh, bejeezles, is she going to start complaining about that again?!? Shut. The. Bagpipes. Up. And. JUST! WRITE!], I’ve read many documents written by people important for the tiny part of history I am focusing on. Some of these people you probably know, seeing as they were important also in a larger context, as Presidents and Prime Ministers in the not too distant past. John F. Kennedy, for instance, is a name I expect will bring out certain memories and images whether you were born in Toledo, Tokyo or Togo. The preexistent ideas we have about people of JFK’s caliber can make it difficult to remain neutral (if that is even a goal, but don’t get me started on post modern historiography).

Most of the time, however, it isn’t the personal notes of Kennedy or Eisenhower or Lyndon B. Johnson I get to read. I read about them, sure, but the day-to-day handling of the specific area of American foreign policy I am interested in (US peace initiatives in the Middle East between 1956 and 1967, in case I haven’t mentioned it before. I have. But you may not have read it. Or cared) didn’t often make it to the President’s desk. It may not even have made it to the Secretary of State’s desk. In the long run a policy is often to a large extent formed by the lower-level officials in the Department.

These are the ones I am surrounded by on a daily basis. These are people who aren’t particularly famous, at least not many of them (though some went on to do greater things later). These are names I had never even heard of only a year ago, but that I now have read so many letters and memos and telegrams and notes to and from that they almost feel like personal acquaintances. I start recognizing patterns – one has a particular way of sugaring pills, another has a tendency to always play the devil’s advocate. I can’t help but try to imagine what they were really like in real life, and before I know it I am no longer neutral to these guys (always guys, by the way. I have so far encountered one single woman in the hundreds of documents I’ve read, and she was a secretary). Based on my impression of these people from these old documents they wrote of records of meetings they attended, I even make up nicknames for some of them. One, his real name shall remain unrevealed for obvious reasons, is currently only known to me as “The Cold-Hearted Bagpipe” (I don’t usually say bagpipe, though…).

The neutrality issue set aside, it is relatively unproblematic that I make up these little stories about the people who otherwise would only be names on an old piece of paper. It is unproblematic because the events I am reading (and occasionally writing) about happened 40-50 years ago. Most of the people involved are long dead. Or so I thought.

I google most of the names that reoccur often enough for me to notice. The reason I do this is both because it is useful for me to know exactly what their position was at the time they wrote that document (the same document can take on an entirely different meaning depending on whether it was written by the director of some government agency or other, or if it was scribbled down by an on-the-floor bureaucrat), and because it is useful to know where they ended up after this job. Especially in the Israeli sources the seemingly unimportant nobodies participating in low-level meetings have a nasty habit of ending up as chief-of-this or minister-of-that. It just looks like you know what you are doing if you are able to mention things like this…

Anyway, there are apparently some glitches in my googling. One of the more prominent members of the state department fraction that dealt with the Middle East during my allotted eleven years, was a gentleman named Phillips Talbot. Now, this one I do feel comfortable mentioning the name of because he is one of the good guys (and before you ask – no, I have no silly nickname for him). From the documents I’ve read I had formed an impression of a respectable, thoughtful, and intelligent man, one who was not afraid to stand up for what he believed was right and one who was also not afraid to introduce fresh ideas in the policy he worked to implement. However, he was also a realistic person, and I don’t think it would have occurred to me to describe him as an idealist from what I have seen from his pen. All in all a solid image, one that lead me to think I knew most of what there was need for me to know about him.

But then I googled him again today, hoping that I’d magically come across some useful information (or some clues as to where I could find such information) about a conference he hosted in 1964. I didn’t find that, but I did find something else. I had never looked at his birth date before, but when I peeked at the Wikipedia page about him I noticed that it said he was born in 1915. Strangely enough, though, it didn’t say when he died. I had never really thought about the possibility that any of the people I encounter in my research could be alive. After all, most of them were in their fifties or sixties already then, so the chances that they were alive now seemed unlikely.

But Phillips Talbot is.

I checked more websites, (I think I’ve been through almost eight pages of google hits on him today,) and the verdict is clear. This man that I assumed was no longer with us is alive and vibrant. He is turning 95 in only a few days, but he seems in no hurry to go anywhere. There were a few interviews with him on YouTube from last summer. He is an elderly – but I wouldn’t say old – man, who still gives me the distinct impression of being respectable, thoughtful and intelligent. The only big difference from the image I had formed about him is that he is still alive!

Now, this doesn’t really change anything. He is still just one of the many people that had an impact on the issues I write my thesis about. The fact that I also found his email address online doesn’t really matter either, because at this point in my research the complexity of adding an oral source and the can of worms that can be just seems too much to deal with. Had he been one of the Presidents or Secretaries of State I would have tried to contact him, but right now I don’t think I will.

Even if this discovery doesn’t change anything, it affects me slightly anyway… Now I know that this is a real, living person. It makes me wonder if I will read his documents differently, or if I will weigh my words more carefully when mentioning him. Even though I decided not to contact him, I can’t help but wonder if this will turn into one of those “what if’s”. What if I had emailed him? Would he have been able to enlighten me on certain things I had overseen or interpreted incorrectly? Further, the discovery that I had overlooked the fact that one of the people I spend every day with, so to speak, is still alive, makes me wonder what else I might have missed. Are there gaping holes in my research that I am blind to? Finally, the things I learned about Talbot’s work before and after he left the Near East division in State Department, while not changing my overall view of him, are already starting to affect the image I had formed. He used to be a journalist. He has a PhD from the University of Chicago. He was the US ambassador to Greece. And his main field of interest was not the Middle East, but rather India where he worked for years, one of them being 1947 when India gained its independence. One of the newspaper articles I read about him described him as a Gandhian.

Writing history is not necessarily about being neutral or objective anymore (here we go with the post modernism again), but nevertheless these remain ideals most historians at least try to approach. We try to be fair. We try to portray history if not “as it was” (courtesy of good ol’ Leopold von Ranke), at least as close to how we perceive how it was as possible. We may not admit it anymore, but we still seek to describe something true, something real. In this respect all this extra information I have gained today may be helpful, because it can help fill gaps in my research. On the other hand, it might be distractive, because Talbot’s (or anyone else’s) belief in Gandhian ideals is irrelevant to my interpretation of the documents that are supposed to be the evidence for my arguments in my thesis.

I thought I knew Mr. Talbot. It turned out there was one very big detail I had missed. Perhaps the best way to deal with this is to accept that I don’t know him, and to leave it at that?

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

On tennis

Meet (probably Dwight) Porter. He is employed in the US State Department (and if it really is Dwight, he would later become the US ambassador to Lebanon). It is September, 1957. Porter has a tennis appointment, on Tuesday. This might be Tuesday 24 September, but more likely it is Tuesday 1 October. Porter is supposed to meet his tennis partner at 11:45 in the lobby of the “big building”.


This is what I know.

It is not specified which building it is, nor the name of the tennis partner, since he is the anonymous scribbler on the back of a document regarding US Near East policy. His little memo to self regarding a mundane (I assume) tennis appointment has been saved for all eternity in the State Department archives; and collected by a random, Norwegian researcher looking for something else entirely.

It is the time of the Edsel, a car that has recently been introduced to the American market. Porter does not yet know – no one does – that this car will become a symbol of failure. Perhaps porter bought an Edsel, perhaps he rode it to his tennis appointment.

It is the time of the Little Rock Crisis – where nine African American students were prevented from attending a racially segregated school in Arkansas. President Eisenhower intervened, and this is today considered to be a very important event in the history of the Civil Rights Movement. Perhaps Porter read about this in the paper the morning he went to play tennis, or perhaps he discussed it with his tennis partner.

Porter might have gone to New York a few days later. If he did, he might have seen a brand new Broadway show, called “West Side Story”. If he liked it, he might have guessed that it would become one of the world’s most famous musicals.

When I come across these personal interventions in the otherwise formal and professional documents it is difficult not to let the thoughts fly. The historical context gives endless opportunities for my imagination to weave a story for the anonymous men who all of a sudden become persons. Unfortunately, I can’t really afford to do so at the moment, since I have a deadline coming up. Blogging is about the last thing I have the time for.

So, this poor blog will once again have to be neglected for a while. I shall return. I promise. If nothing else, to report on (possibly Dwight) Porter. I’ll let you know if I find any further tennis appointments.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

On research

48 Address by President Eisenhower, 20 February 1957, published in Department of State Bulletin, 11 March 1957.


The above is an actual footnote from my actual thesis. For your enjoyment (and mine – you have no idea how funny I think it is to have a footnote at the top of a page. MAN this thesis writing is messing with my head!).

I promise I won’t start using footnotes in my blog, though. Not because I don’t enjoy footnotes (as proved by the above), but because I recognize that there are different kinds of research and documentation required for different kinds of writing. When writing blog posts, for instance, I usually settle for whatever I can find via Google and/or Wikipedia. I am aware that there are issues regarding the use of online sources, but after years of training I usually find it relatively easy to distinguish the serious stuff from what is obviously fabricated. Besides, my blog posts very rarely require heavy research.

When writing fiction, I tend to take my research more seriously. I spend more time on it, I check several sources to make sure my information is accurate and I try to fit the fictional details in with the factual ones to make sure it flows without losing context.

Finally, the most intense way of research for me is what I do academically. Working with my thesis has taught me a lot about how to (and how not to) research. I’ve spent time in an archive, photographing and classifying original documents that I have later read and reread and then reread again. I’ve looked at monographs, biographies, and anthologies. I’ve been through thousands of pages of secondary sources, where renowned historians (and some not so renowned – that’s part of the process too) have considered the same or similar sources as me, and drawn their conclusions that may or may not differ with mine.

It would never occur to me to use Wikipedia in research for my thesis. Even though I know that a lot of the material on Wikipedia is serious and useful, the potential for errors is too big in a medium consisting of whatever its users put into it. Besides, it simply would not look good in my bibliography (which, naturally, is of crucial importance). Finally, when you are writing about sensitive topics such as the Middle East conflict, the potential traps by not being critical towards your sources are endless. Today I am capable of recognizing bias in texts on the Middle East (often based on something as simple as the choice of words), but two years ago I wouldn’t have been. In a medium like Wikipedia it would almost be unnatural if the articles about the Middle East weren’t biased.

Likewise, it would not occur to me to consult an archive before writing a blog post. It would not make sense to spend that much time and money (I travelled across an ocean, you know) on a blog and the format of the blog does not require it. In fact, I think it would probably be detrimental for the purpose of most blogs to spend too much time on research (depending on the topic of the blog, naturally).

Each kind of writing requires its own type of research, and it is important to find what fits your kind of writing. At least, that is my (hard-earned, I might add) experience.







Good giraffe – I just wrote a writing blog! Giraffes must be flying!

Thursday, October 1, 2009

On blogging about nothing

Oh, my great Digression – I have nothing to blog about today!


No funky telegrams have been found; no odd weather phenomena have struck me to the ground; no language related craziness has come in my way lately (though it did take me a while to figure out what the plural of phenomenon was, since Phenomena to me only is a YA fantasy series I reluctantly sell to teenagers or their moms every now and then back home).

I suppose I could write about how my throat all of a sudden feels sore and how I hope it isn’t the swine flu, or any other kind of flu, for that matter – but I feel that this has been done (and it is more of a Facebook status update kind of thing anyway). I could write about the lady in the office next to mine who has the annoying habit of putting a question mark at the end of every sentence? But then again, I already did use that as a Facebook status update? (Plus I think it would be annoying to write an entire blog filled with question marks?)

There is always the possibility of writing a book review, but I’ve never been very good at that – I tend to be overly afraid of giving away anything, which is all nice and cotton candy, but it doesn’t make for a good book review if you can’t say zilch about what happens in the book. Besides, I’m in the middle of a book at the moment (Going Bovine, which is highly entertaining, though I suspect tears towards the end), and the previous book I read has already been mentioned in this blog – and even though Pandora in the Congo was an interesting book that I’d highly recommend if you’re looking for a good, but not necessarily mainstream read, I’m not sure it’s entitled to both an anecdote and a review within a couple of weeks.

Since I only have one month left in the US now, I ought to take the opportunity to write page up and page down on all the American oddities I find, or the cultural differences that sooner or later surely will send me straight into cultural shock. However, I find that the differences can either be overcome easily, or they are not that big in the first place. Or maybe I’m just awesomely superior at adapting? Either way, the biggest challenge isn’t the difference in culture, but the fact that my friends and family are far away. And who wants to read a blog where I complain about missing those at home, eh? I could spice it up with how I am not sure if I like or dislike the fact that soup comes in cans rather than “mix-with-water-powder-packs” here; or how I have discovered that I really hate that the cashier packs your groceries for you – it takes FOREVER; but again, I don’t think it makes a great blog. It makes boring blog. Boring blog bad.

My very last idea is to find a random picture from my personal archive (it’s called “the Internet” – haha – kidding… I try to use my own pictures whenever possible, but every now and then I find my own set of images just doesn’t cover it – if I for some reason should need a picture of a cucumber, it would be a lot easier to try to find one online instead of going to the store, buy a cucumber, take it home, take a picture, upload it to my computer and from there to my blog. Too much work. Wow – I almost forgot that I still was inside a parenthesis there). I could do that. But the first very random picture I found was the one below, and frankly, there’s not all that much to say about good, old Axil of Evil (other than that he was the result of what an already corrupted mind did to a frequent typo back when I was writing about North Korea and not the Middle East. We love them conflicts, don’t we?).



So, to conclude, I am very sorry, but I have absolutely nothing to blog about today.

Thursday, September 24, 2009

On the Middle East

I came across some photographs in one of the archive boxes I was working in the other day. Normally, anything that isn’t a telegram, airgram, memorandum of conversation or – always a favourite – a letter to the president from a desperate housewife, is welcome. However, these weren’t photographs you were supposed to enjoy.


They showed the remains of some villages at the West Bank in (at the time) Jordan, destroyed in one of the many “border incidents” between Jordan and Israel. What mostly got to me when watching these pictures, however, was not the horridness of the photographs themselves – demolished houses; the remains of a child’s bed (I don’t want to know what happened to the child); sad-looking people outside what used to be their homes. No, what really struck me was the realization that nothing has changed. These pictures were taken in 1966, but aside from the fact that they were black-and-white, they might as well have been taken yesterday. It illustrates a tragic side effect to living in constant conflict for more than 60 years: these areas have next to no chance of any development – politically, financially or otherwise. It makes me terribly angry and equally sad that the conflict that back then already had been going on for almost a generation is still hindering the development today.

As a historian it is important to try to keep one’s distance to the material one studies; and above all, to try to not be prejudiced in ones findings (the historian’s task is more complex than what I depict here, but I’m conveniently skipping any methodological or theoretical debate since a) I don’t think it belongs here; b) I know for a fact it would bore you all; and c) it would also bore me). However, seeing pictures like these; reading hundreds upon hundreds of documents about the “border incidents” of various gravity; and knowing that after the events of which I am currently reading followed more than 40 years of equal or worse – with no imminent prospects of improvement even today – it is hard not to draw at least one conclusion: there must be a lot of people whose intentions are to avoid peace in the Middle East. Otherwise, why would the parties in the conflict continue, doing the same things they have been doing for decades? Continuous attacks – from either side – with the inevitable retaliations, will not lead to peace. Falsely claiming to want negotiations to win political victories, internally or externally, will not lead to peace. The conflict in the Middle East will not go away if we stop paying attention to it, just as it will not go away if we pay attention merely by distributing blame.

It can be depressing, to say the least, to study the quagmire that is the Arab-Israeli conflict. In addition, my time-frame spans a eleven years when the patterns that were to dominate the conflict the following decades were forming. I can see – quite clearly – that it goes wrong, but I cannot do anything about it. Unfortunately, it seems that taking a step back in order to reset those patterns does not appear to be an option for the parties involved – today, as it wasn’t forty or fifty or sixty years ago. It’s out of fashion for historians to believe we can “learn from history”, but nevertheless – wouldn’t it be worth trying?
Related Posts with Thumbnails